Featured on Fenomena Seni.
I was studying when I was informed by
TV smith to take a look at RTM 1. I missed most of the arguments, and parts of me are glad I did because I got to hear the panelists championing some lovely, hot, heaping bigotry.
The show (Fenomena Seni) is hosted by Rosyam Nor and features talks films and culture on Sunday nights from 8.30 to 10.30 PM. I am really not sure who the panelists were today, I would appreciate it if someone could fill me in (It's good to keep your enemies close I hear).
I know this is a really bad exercise in journalism because it was written in haste (have to study) and with much too much emotion (very angry), but I'm going to take the excuse that this is a personal blog and talk about it anyways because I feel damn strongly about it. So much of what was said was unbelievably hurting to me, and I'm extremely dissapointed with the kind of close-minded, bigoted thinking we have in Malaysia.
Either way, some excerpts from the RTM 1 live show of the debate on whether Sepet dan Gubra, Pencemar Budaya.
1st Gentleman : Akmal AbdullahHe mentioned that Sepet wasn't a social reality and if so, only a narrow one at that. His relative married a Chinese and that particular Chinese man was very open to accepting Islam etc. Very much unlike how Yasmin portrays it in her movies. All of sudden midway, he started to get a little disgruntled and talked about how a Malay person could "
masuk kedai babi?"
- We all know its not the social reality, I mentioned this in my post before. It does show a narrow view of our society, but that is the world to some of us, lest we forget. Also, it may be idealistic but the movie also does try and show us values that we are lacking in (such as genuine acceptance of other races and religion).2nd Gentleman : Hassan Abd MuthalibYasmin's film is Malaysian as stated by FINAS regulations. It has "
bangsa-bangsa asing yang menjadi players dalam pembikinan filem."
-
The fact that someone has to mention bangsa-bangsa asing (foreign races) to describe "my kind" which is just as Malaysian as he is, is so bloody dissapointing to say the least. Read it again and tell me how horrible it sounds, why that was even mentioned or in what context it was said in remains a mystery to me. What race has to do with anything actually? But then again in Malaysia, everything and absolutely everything has to do with the color of your skin.*edit*I misquoted Mr. Hassan, see comments, fully understand his context now, apologies:
Hassan Abd Muthalib said...
Hey, I've been misquoted! (it's not the first time). What I actually said was that Yasmin's films fit in with the FINAS slogan 'Filem Malaysia Era Globalisasi' & that now there are new players from the other races in the industry (which should be accepted).
3rd Lady : Director of Movies *edit* shwumacher said...
*edited again*
Raja Azmi was the producer of Black Widow Wajah Ayu and wrote the screenplay for Cinta 200 Ela..she however, wasn't the director of those movies. Black Widow was directed by U-wei and Cinta was directed by Shadan Hashim. Still, this does not absolve her from the prejudices she reflected on the show last night.
Once again, do help if you saw the whole show. This is extremely infuriating. She was the worst, most bigoted one of all! Since I first saw her talking all she could say was how Islam wasn't delivered well in the show, Malaysia's multi-culturalism has been known to exist for a long time it is unnecessary to show it, because we (Malaysians) have accepted it for so long already.
Malaysia ialah TANAH MELAYU and something along the lines of
Orang Melayu yang berbudi bahasa have let the other races be here with full acceptance and tolerance.
- Aww thank you, how nice of you!The fact that we are having this debate strikes me as odd. One of the callers, Haris said it perfectly well. There are far more damaging movies being shown everyday that have violence, sex, and other detrimental elements that might affect the oh-so delicate Malaysian audience, so why is it that a love story should receive this kind of extensive coverage?
Because, it is about a Chinese boy falling in love with a Muslim girl.Not even about her Melayu-ness! But, about a Muslim girl who is brought up in a liberal Islamic family, where parents are pretty vocal about their love for each other and behave as most married couples normally do in the privacy of their own homes. Because Orked, our beautifully
baju-kurunged heroine walked into a
kedai babi! Oh the shock. All our sensibilities down the proverbial drain, eh? Can't handle it. Cannnnot.
Mana boleh macam tu! Mesti kena marah!I am all for the fact that Sepet and/or Gubra aren't the epitome of Malaysian social realities. In fact, it is extremely idealistic to have such displays of humility, love, and respect in real life. In fact, watching it made me cringe in disbelief that there exists this very same thoughts (of an ideally Utopian Malaysia) in someone else's mind, other than my own!
But the question I pose to you is this:
What in God's name is so wrong with the world Yasmin Ahmad has created in Sepet and Gubra and how does it pollute our culture?Are there riots? Are people getting hurt and offended in Orked's world? Or is there patience, humility and love for your fellow men- despite the fact that they are sometimes women who sell their bodies for money? Or the fact that they might have AIDS and you've volunteered to teach them how to read the Quran?
Raja Azmi said right before she summarised, that Yasmin's delivery of Islam was wrong and convoluted. It was not delivered in the right way, and the bad highlighting of Islam overshadowed the good.
Listen to me.I am Catholic. I am non-Muslim. I am non-Malay. I am a Malaysian citizen. I am 23 years of age and was registered to vote since 2 months ago. I am second generation Malaysian.Most of all, I am in love with this country.The movie highlighted the very way we should try to be in Malaysia, every single day. I'm not advocating mixed-marriages (I am however, very much in favor of it) or walking into
kedai babi's, but look at the good the movie has shown us. Why do people never ever do that? The lady talks about how Islam was cast in a bad light so much so, it overshadowed the good in Islam.
Are you blind, woman?
The movie made me want to weep because Islam is
supposed to be practised in that way. Sadly, in Malaysia, I haven't been exposed to many people who do practice that brand of Islam. You say you're shocked that a woman as pious as Yasmin made the movie that way... In what way?
A movie highlighting the
genuiness of your religion? So much so it brought me to tears, that someone could have so much compassion for his fellow man? Ask any non-Muslim on the street, go on
ASK THEM what they thought of the Islam in Gubra and you will hear confessions of "How I wish it were truly that way...."
Maybe some of you out there -and I am sure many of you will have a problem with me saying this- should look back into yourselves.... in that secret place only you go to, and ask yourselves are you being fair to Yasmin and the Malaysians you meet in your daily lives, but most of all are you being fair to yourselves?
Are you showing the best of your humanity to your fellow man?
All I know is, I walked away extremely
berdukacita and most importantly,
tercemar...
I feel bad for Yasmin, I sure do hope she has thick skin.
* See also Nazrul
* See a Malay review by MUTEAUDIO
Ed's Note: I apologise for the misquotes and have edited them where necessary. It was a very emotional post therefore might be lacking in clarity, if you do need me to clarify anything please drop me a line at meeshlet AT gmail DOT com
Thank you for reading and thank you for pointing out errors, as someone said, writing is all about rewriting :P